Lexington Avenue · Since 1985
We craft one-of-a-kind pieces that carry your moments forward — from engagement rings that start conversations to heirlooms you'll tell your grandchildren about.
40+
Years Serving NYC
100%
Custom Designs
GIA
Certified Stones
"Every piece tells a story that's uniquely yours."
What We Do
From a sketch to a finished piece, we bring your vision to life — whether it's an engagement ring, a birthday gift, or a complete collection.
Broken clasp, worn prong, or a piece that needs new life — our skilled artisans restore your jewelry to its original brilliance.
Professional, detailed appraisals for insurance, estate planning, or resale — backed by industry standards and decades of expertise.
Diamonds, sapphires, emeralds — we guide you through every clarity, cut, and carat so you find the perfect stone with confidence.
Add a name, a date, a whispered promise. Our precision engraving turns a beautiful piece into a deeply personal keepsake.
Browse our curated selection of ready-to-wear pieces — timeless designs crafted for everyday elegance and special occasions alike.
Est.
1985
Our Story
For over four decades, Lexington Jeweler has been a quiet cornerstone on Lexington Avenue — a place where New Yorkers come not just to buy jewelry, but to have something made that truly belongs to them.
Every ring, every chain, every restored heirloom that leaves our workshop carries the same standard: honest materials, careful hands, and a respect for the traditions that make fine jewelry last generations, not seasons.
GIA
Certified Diamonds
18K
Gold & Platinum
Free
Consultations
Same
Day Repair Service
Our Work
Client Words
"They designed an engagement ring that perfectly captured what my partner and I wanted — it was unlike anything I'd seen in the window displays. The attention to detail was extraordinary."
— A Lexington Ave. Neighbor
"I brought in my grandmother's broken bracelet — I thought it was beyond saving. Within a week, it was back on my wrist looking better than ever. These are the kind of craftsmen you don't find everywhere."
— Upper East Side Client
"Honest, patient, and genuinely knowledgeable. They never pushed me toward anything I didn't need and helped me understand every step of the process. That's rare these days."
— Midtown Regular
Start Your Piece
Whether you're envisioning something entirely new or restoring a treasured heirloom, we're here to help you every step of the way.
Visit Us
1236 Lexington Ave
New York, NY 10028
212-744-4140
Call or text anytime
paulthejeweler@aol.com
We respond within 24 hours
Hours
Monday – Friday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday: By Appointment Only
